#5 Silent Hill - [ PS2 ]
Silent Hill is the perfect "scary movie" experience that is guaranteed to have her clutching your arm. Warm up some popcorn, curl up under a blanket and turn out all the lights because Silent Hill is all about the atmosphere. If she's into it and you can play your cards right, then you're in for a fun evening. If not then you need to consider a new game... or a new girlfriend.